- One recent analysis concluded that ultraprocessed foods (UPFs) may be as addictive as tobacco products.
- The study authors observed that UPFs are formulated to heighten reward and speed up the absorption of reinforcing ingredients.
- The “addictive” property of such products means they fuel compulsive consumption and hinder appetite regulation.
- The review authors propose that UPFs could be governed by controls comparable to those for tobacco products.
At present, there is not a universal description of UPFs. Some people define them as products that include additives you are unlikely to have in a home kitchen, for instance stabilizers and artificial substances.
A lot of dietitians use the NOVA classification to identify UPFs. This refers to products that contain “combinations of components, primarily of manufacturing origin, often made by a series of factory processes and methods.”
One new analysis featured in The Millbank Quarterly proposed that UPFs could be as addictive as cigarettes.
“I concur with these findings, as UPFs are intentionally formulated to be highly appealing to most individuals,” stated a bariatric surgeon independent from the study.
A study from 2023 calculates that more than 73% of the food supply in the US is classified as ultraprocessed.
“Cigarettes and ultraprocessed foods are not just natural products but carefully designed consumable products engineered deliberately to maximize physical and mental reinforcement and compulsive consumption,” wrote the review’s scientists.
Can UPFs Addictive?
This analysis synthesized findings from addiction, public health history, and nutrition to pinpoint textural and compositional characteristics that enhance the rewarding nature of both tobacco and ultraprocessed foods.
“It’s not all people is ‘hooked’ to these foods, but for a sizable group, they cause typical addiction-like behaviors: strong cravings, loss of control, and persistent consumption even with harmful consequences,” said a heart health nutrition expert.
“These products are purposely formulated with refined carbs, added fats, sodium, and taste additives to maximize reward and repeat consumption, and the food sector uses aggressive marketing tactics, especially targeting young people,” she stated.
Scientists focused on several important factors:
- delivery speed
- pleasure-based design, or creating products to be irresistibly good
- perfecting the amount
- widespread availability
- deceptive reformulation, or “wellness branding”
It was observed that, like tobacco, ultraprocessed foods are carefully calibrated to provide the optimal amount of sweetness.
“Refined carbohydrates stimulate dopamine production through the vagus nerve, while fats do so via fat detection in the gut,” the researchers wrote.
“… UPFs with high levels of refined carbohydrates and extra oils are among the most potently rewarding foods in the modern diet. Importantly this refined carbohydrate-fat combination is almost nonexistent in nature.”
How these foods rapidly deliver “pleasure-inducing” chemicals to the brain renders them potentially addictive, similarly to cigarettes.
The paper stated that while tobacco are engineered to deliver nicotine quickly, ultraprocessed foods are engineered to be broken down and absorbed quickly, as they usually have minimal dietary fiber. This allows for the system to process lipids and carbohydrates faster.
Authors also point out that UPFs provide deliberate flavor bursts that dissipate rapidly and mouthfeels that melt in your mouth. This all helps to deliver more dopamine and prompts you to consume additional amounts.
‘Health Washing’ in Tobacco, UPFs
Based on the analysis, both the tobacco and processed food industries have long used a strategy known as “wellness branding.”
This refers to when goods are marketed and altered to create an perception of less danger while maintaining the core of their properties.
Health washing in the tobacco industry became popular in the 1950s with the introduction of filter tips on cigarettes.
These were marketed as safety features that would trap harmful substances prior to they entered the lungs. Actually, filters provide little significant benefit.
However, people typically adapted by taking bigger puffs or smoking more frequently, which negated any decrease in harmful intake.
The food industry has adopted a similar approach. It employs packaging claims such as “reduced fat” or “no sugar added” to promote ultraprocessed foods.
Yet, these items still contain the very highly reinforcing ingredient combinations. The problem is that these changes offer a surface-level impression of wellness while the item’s habit-forming nature and health risks remain intact.
Ought UPFs Be Regulated?
The researchers noted at the conclusion of their review that food and smoking products are fundamentally different.
Still, they cautioned that some UPFs act like highly optimized products rather than actual food. They proposed that health regulations ought to acknowledge this reality.
“Tobacco offers a cautionary tale, and smoking regulations provides a model of hope,” the authors wrote.
Because of regulations, cigarette use levels in the US have declined and have “reshaped public perception of tobacco and eroded trust in the sector.”
“I believe greater education regarding the negative impact of UPFs is essential to lower general consumption and improve public health. The approaches used to curb tobacco consumption have been effective and may be a helpful blueprint for ultra-processed foods as well,” said one expert.
“It is not my view ultraprocessed foods should be controlled precisely as cigarettes, but they certainly deserve stronger, tobacco-inspired policies: advertising limits, obvious front-of-package labeling, tighter standards on wellness assertions, and restrictions in schools or hospitals,” added another dietitian.
The researchers pointed out to people that lightly altered and whole foods have sustained human health for thousands of years.